Introduction
Attorney Richard Nicotra has practiced personal injury law in Western and Central New York for over 27 years, a tenure that earned him the Presidents Award from the New York State Trial Lawyers Association Western Region Affiliate. The Nicotra Law Firm, PC maintains offices in both Buffalo and Rochester, positioning the firm to serve clients across a wide stretch of Upstate New York from the Lake Erie corridor to the Finger Lakes region.
Practice Areas
The Nicotra Law Firm concentrates on personal injury cases arising from accidents and incidents across several categories:
Vehicle Accidents: The firm handles claims from car accidents, motorcycle accidents, truck accidents, bus accidents, bicycle accidents, and pedestrian accidents. Each vehicle type carries distinct insurance considerations and liability frameworks, and the firm’s long experience in Western New York courts reflects familiarity with how these cases develop locally.
Rideshare Accidents: Injuries involving Uber, Lyft, and other rideshare platforms introduce layered insurance questions not present in standard auto accident claims. The firm represents clients injured in or by rideshare vehicles.
Slip and Fall: Premises liability cases arising from unsafe floor conditions, inadequate lighting, ice or snow accumulation, and similar hazards fall within the firm’s practice. Property owners in New York carry specific duties to people lawfully on their premises.
Construction Accidents: New York’s Labor Law provisions create significant liability for property owners and general contractors when workers are injured on construction sites. The firm handles these claims for injured workers throughout its service area.
Dog Bites: New York imposes liability on dog owners for injuries caused by their animals. The firm pursues these claims on behalf of people bitten or otherwise injured by dogs.
Boat Accidents: The western and central New York region includes substantial waterway activity on Lake Erie, the Niagara River, and other bodies of water. The firm handles injury claims arising from boating accidents.
Wrongful Death: When negligence results in a fatality, surviving family members may pursue a wrongful death claim. The Nicotra Law Firm represents families in these cases.
Attorney Profiles
Richard Nicotra founded the firm and has practiced personal injury law for more than 27 years. The New York State Trial Lawyers Association Western Region Affiliate recognized his work with its Presidents Award, a designation that reflects standing among peers in the Western New York legal community.
Andrew Connelly is an attorney at the firm who works on the personal injury matters the practice handles across its Buffalo and Rochester locations.
Emily Oczytko is an attorney at the firm contributing to client representation in personal injury cases throughout the service area.
The firm reports a 99.9% success rate in the cases it accepts, a figure that reflects both the selectivity applied to case intake and the results the team has achieved in contested matters.
Location & Service Area
The Nicotra Law Firm operates from two offices:
- Buffalo, New York (primary Western New York location)
- Rochester, New York (Central New York location)
The firm serves clients throughout Buffalo, Erie County, Niagara County, Cattaraugus County, and Chautauqua County in the west, as well as Rochester, Monroe County, Canandaigua, Ontario County, Genesee County, Wyoming County, and Yates County further east. This geographic footprint covers a substantial portion of Upstate New York.
Contact: 716-333-0043 or 866-NICOTRA
Website: 866nicotra.com/
Client Focus
The Nicotra Law Firm works on a contingency fee basis, meaning clients pay no attorney fees unless the firm achieves a successful outcome. Free consultations are available, and the firm accommodates clients who cannot come in during standard business hours through evening and weekend appointment availability. This flexibility matters for people managing injuries or work obligations alongside the demands of pursuing a legal claim.
The firm’s two-office structure means that clients in Rochester do not need to travel to Buffalo for representation, and the geographic reach across twelve counties reflects a deliberate effort to serve the full Western and Central New York region rather than limiting intake to a single metropolitan area.
FAQ
Does the firm handle accidents that happen outside of Buffalo and Rochester proper?
Yes. The firm’s service area includes Erie, Niagara, Cattaraugus, and Chautauqua counties in the west and Monroe, Ontario, Genesee, Wyoming, and Yates counties in the east, covering communities well beyond the two major cities where the offices are located.
What does a contingency fee arrangement mean for clients?
Under a contingency fee arrangement, the firm only collects attorney fees if it recovers money for the client. There are no upfront legal fees to retain the firm or to pursue a case to resolution.
Can I schedule an appointment outside of regular business hours?
The firm offers evening and weekend appointments for clients who need to meet at times other than standard weekday business hours.
What is the Presidents Award from the New York State Trial Lawyers Association?
The Presidents Award is a recognition given by the Western Region Affiliate of the New York State Trial Lawyers Association. It reflects Richard Nicotra’s standing and contribution to the personal injury plaintiff bar in Western New York over his more than 27-year career.
Does the firm handle rideshare accident cases?
Yes. The firm represents clients injured in accidents involving Uber, Lyft, and other rideshare platforms, which involve distinct insurance and liability questions compared to standard auto accident claims.
Closing
The Nicotra Law Firm’s combination of a long-established practice, dual-office coverage across Western and Central New York, and a team that includes both founding and associate attorneys gives clients in this region access to personal injury representation with deep local knowledge. Richard Nicotra’s 27-year tenure and peer recognition from the New York State Trial Lawyers Association reflect a consistent track record in a practice area where local court experience and insurer relationships matter significantly to outcomes.