Introduction

In 2018, a 10-year-old boy named Ethan Isaacs was fatally struck by a boat propeller while participating in youth sailing practice in Sarasota, Florida. He was hit by the boat because the operator had no kill switch attached to their body, a device that would have stopped the engine the moment the operator fell or was thrown overboard. Florida Representative Fiona McFarland subsequently championed legislation requiring operators of watercraft under 26 feet to wear attached kill switches. The Haggard Law Firm, operating as Aquatic Attorneys, tracked that legislation closely, and the firm’s engagement with Ethan’s Law is not incidental. It reflects the firm’s core position: boating accidents are not inevitable tragedies. They are, in most cases, the result of specific, identifiable acts of negligence by operators, companies, or manufacturers who had the ability to prevent harm and did not.

The Haggard Law Firm’s aquatic injury practice operates from Coral Gables, Florida at 330 Alhambra Circle, and the firm handles cases nationally. Boating accident victims and families of drowning victims can access the firm for free consultations, and legal fees are collected only if cases are won.


Practice Areas

Boating Accidents and Propeller Strike Cases

Propeller strikes represent one of the most severe and preventable categories of boating injury. A propeller rotating at operating speed can cause catastrophic or fatal injuries in fractions of a second. The legal question in propeller strike cases turns on what the operator, rental company, or manufacturer did or failed to do: Was a kill switch available? Was it worn? Was the victim a swimmer, a skier, or a person who had fallen from the boat? What was the operator’s speed, attention level, and familiarity with the waterway?

The death of Ethan Isaacs, and the legislation that followed, illustrates the preventability of this specific injury category. The firm’s engagement with that case and that law positions it to address propeller strike cases with an understanding of both the technical standards that govern safe watercraft operation and the legal obligations that attach to operators and rental companies.

Boating Collisions and Drownings

Collisions between watercraft, and between watercraft and stationary objects, follow patterns of operator negligence that parallel land-based vehicle accidents: inattention, speed, alcohol, and failure to yield. Drowning cases in boating contexts raise liability questions involving vessel stability, personal flotation device availability and condition, operator conduct, and the circumstances under which a person entered the water.

Liability Against Private Boat Owners

The owner of a privately operated vessel bears responsibility for the vessel’s operation and condition. When the owner is also the operator, that responsibility is direct. When an owner permits another person to operate their vessel and that person causes harm, questions of negligent entrustment and owner liability arise. The firm evaluates all potentially liable parties, including the vessel owner, in every case it takes on.

Rental Company Liability

Boat rental companies have obligations that go beyond handing over a key. They must inspect and maintain their fleet, ensure renters are adequately instructed in vessel operation, and not rent to operators who are visibly impaired or demonstrably unqualified. Failures at any of these points can establish liability when a rented vessel causes injury. Commercial rental companies also carry insurance that is different in scale from private owner policies, which is relevant to potential recovery.

Manufacturer Liability

When a vessel’s design, manufacturing defect, or inadequate safety warning contributes to an injury, the manufacturer may bear legal responsibility. Propulsion system design, hull stability, safety equipment requirements, and the adequacy of operator warnings are all areas where manufacturer defects can produce injuries. The firm evaluates manufacturer liability as part of every boating accident case.

National Practice

The aquatic injury practice operates nationally, not only in Florida. Boating accident victims and surviving family members throughout the United States can contact the firm. Florida law governs many matters given the state’s significance as a center of recreational boating, but the firm’s national scope means it can represent clients whose accidents occurred on waterways in other states.


Firm Focus

The Haggard Law Firm occupies a distinct niche in personal injury law. The aquatic injury practice is specialized in a way that general personal injury firms are not. Boating accident cases require knowledge of Coast Guard regulations, state boating laws, vessel inspection standards, and the technical aspects of watercraft operation and design that differ fundamentally from automobile accident cases. The firm has developed that specific competency.

The engagement with Florida’s “Ethan’s Law” legislative process illustrates what specialized practice looks like in action. The firm did not simply take cases that happened to involve water. It tracked the development of the legal and regulatory framework governing kill switch requirements, understood the factual context that produced that legislation, and positioned itself to apply that regulatory knowledge to client cases. That is the difference between general personal injury practice with occasional water accidents and a genuine aquatic injury specialty.

The “negligence rather than chance” framework is central to the firm’s philosophy. Boating accidents are often described publicly as freak accidents or tragedies without assignable fault. The firm’s consistent position is that most of them result from identifiable acts of negligence. That framing matters for potential clients who may believe their accident was simply bad luck. In most cases, it was not.


Location and National Service

The Haggard Law Firm is located at:

330 Alhambra Circle
Coral Gables, FL 33134

The firm handles aquatic injury and drowning cases nationally. Clients outside Florida are welcome to contact the firm for case evaluation. Consultations are free, and legal fees are contingent on case recovery.


Client Focus

Aquatic injury and drowning cases often involve families who have suffered catastrophic losses. A child killed by a propeller. A recreational boater who drowns after a collision. A water skier struck by another vessel. These are not abstract legal matters. The clients who retain the firm are frequently in the worst periods of their lives, and the firm’s ability to handle these cases nationally means that geography is not a barrier to accessing specialized representation.

The no-fee-unless-won structure reflects the firm’s confidence in its case evaluation process. The firm assesses cases carefully before taking them, and the contingency structure means the firm’s financial interest is aligned with the client’s: maximum recovery, or no payment.

Consultations are free. Clients can present the facts of their case, understand whether a legal claim exists, and evaluate the firm before making any commitment.


Frequently Asked Questions

What is “Ethan’s Law” and why does it matter for Florida boating accident cases?
Ethan’s Law refers to Florida legislation championed by Representative Fiona McFarland requiring operators of watercraft under 26 feet to wear kill switches attached to their bodies. The law was named for 10-year-old Ethan Isaacs, who was fatally struck by a boat propeller in Sarasota during a youth sailing event. The legislation creates a specific legal standard: watercraft operators of covered vessels are required to use attached kill switches. A violation of this requirement in an accident that caused injury is evidence of negligence, and the Haggard Law Firm’s familiarity with this law’s development and application positions it to use that regulatory framework in propeller strike cases.

Can I pursue a boating accident claim if the accident occurred outside Florida?
Yes. The firm handles aquatic injury cases nationally. The applicable law depends on where the accident occurred, but the firm’s national practice means it can represent clients whose cases arise on waterways in other states. Contact the firm for a free case evaluation regardless of where your accident occurred.

What if the boat operator who caused the accident did not own the vessel?
Multiple parties may be liable in a boating accident. The operator may be personally liable for negligent operation. The owner may be liable for negligent entrustment if they permitted an unqualified person to operate their vessel. A rental company may be liable for inadequate screening or instruction. A manufacturer may be liable if equipment failure contributed to the accident. The firm evaluates all potentially liable parties as part of case assessment.

How long do I have to file a boating accident claim in Florida?
Florida’s general statute of limitations for personal injury claims is four years from the date of injury. Wrongful death claims have a two-year statute of limitations. Claims against government entities have shorter deadlines and specific notice requirements. These deadlines are firm: missing them typically bars the claim permanently. Early legal consultation ensures these timelines are identified and protected.

What evidence is most valuable in a boating accident case?
Photographs of the vessels and the accident location, the official accident report filed with the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission or the relevant state agency, witness contact information, medical records documenting injuries, and any video footage from the scene or nearby vessels. The operator’s certification history and any records of prior violations are also relevant. The firm can advise on evidence collection and preservation specific to the facts of each case.


Closing

Boating accidents leave a specific kind of damage: catastrophic physical injury or death, on the water, in circumstances where the victim or surviving family often does not know where to turn for specialized legal help. General personal injury attorneys handle car accidents and slip-and-falls. The Haggard Law Firm handles the water. Its aquatic injury specialty, legislative engagement with Florida boating safety law, and national practice reach mean that wherever a boating accident occurred and however serious the resulting harm, the firm has the specialized knowledge to evaluate and pursue the claim. Free consultations are available. Legal fees apply only to successful cases.

Website: aquaticattorney.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *