Go to the listings
Attorney Index US

Mooney Law

Profile brought up to date

Introduction

Attorney Mark Buterbaugh was born, raised, and practices in the communities he serves, a distinction that matters when a workers’ compensation attorney needs to know the employers, the employers’ insurance carriers, the Workers’ Compensation Judges in the region, and the practical realities of how injured workers live in Franklin, Cumberland, Adams, York, Lancaster, and Lebanon counties. His firm, Mooney Law, has collected tens of millions of dollars for injured workers in Pennsylvania and Maryland from five offices across south-central Pennsylvania.

Buterbaugh holds a 9.5 Avvo rating, received the Clients Choice Award 2024, is recognized by National Trial Lawyers as a Top 25 Workers’ Compensation Attorney in Pennsylvania, and is listed by Super Lawyers. He is licensed in both Pennsylvania and Maryland, which directly serves the many south-central Pennsylvania residents who cross the border for work and face Maryland Workers’ Compensation Commission claims when they are injured on the job.

Mooney Law operates from Chambersburg at 80 North Second Street, Carlisle at 213 South Hanover Street, Shippensburg at 34 West King Street, Hanover at 230 York Street, and Lebanon at 346 S. Ninth Street. The main phone number is 717-200-HELP, with Hanover and Lebanon reachable at 717-632-4656. Free consultations are available Monday through Friday, 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM, by phone, Zoom, or in person.

Practice Areas

Mooney Law’s practice centers on Pennsylvania workers’ compensation with a specific focus on south-central Pennsylvania’s workforce.

Workers’ compensation claims from initial filing through appeal form the core of the practice. This includes handling temporary total disability benefits when an injured worker cannot return to their job, fighting benefit stoppages when employers or their insurers attempt to terminate or suspend payments, and navigating the income offset and credit provisions that can affect how much a worker actually receives. Buterbaugh represents clients at Workers’ Compensation Judge hearings and has experience with the transitions that come when WCJ assignments change during a case.

Independent Medical Examination (IME) attendance is a specific dimension of workers’ compensation practice that Buterbaugh addresses. Pennsylvania employers have the right to require injured workers to submit to IMEs by doctors selected by the employer’s insurer. These examinations are structured to support the insurer’s position rather than the injured worker’s, and having legal counsel involved in the IME process protects the worker’s interests.

Light duty work issues arise when employers offer modified duty positions to injured workers as a way to reduce or terminate workers’ compensation benefits. The legal standards governing whether an employer’s light duty offer is bona fide, and whether a worker’s refusal or inability to accept it affects their benefits, require careful legal analysis. Buterbaugh handles these situations as part of his full workers’ compensation practice.

Settlement negotiations for workers’ compensation claims are a significant part of the practice. The formulas used to calculate workers’ compensation settlements in Pennsylvania involve permanent impairment ratings, wage loss calculations, and future medical expense projections. Getting these calculations right requires an attorney who understands both the legal framework and the practical realities of how insurers approach settlement.

Maryland Workers’ Compensation Commission claims are handled for the significant population of Pennsylvania residents who commute across the state line for work. Maryland’s workers’ compensation system has its own separate procedures, and Buterbaugh’s Maryland license makes him one of the few Central Pennsylvania attorneys who can represent these clients without referring them elsewhere.

Dog bite cases are a secondary practice area. The firm notes that in 2021 dog bite attacks accounted for nearly one-third of homeowner insurance claims nationally, totaling approximately $881 million in damages. Pennsylvania law allows dog bite victims to recover from owners in certain circumstances, including where the owner knew the dog was aggressive. The firm handles these claims alongside its workers’ compensation work.

Warehouse injury claims along the Interstate 81 corridor represent a growing part of the practice. South-central Pennsylvania has seen substantial distribution and logistics facility development along the I-81 corridor, bringing with it a large warehouse workforce exposed to the specific injury risks of that industry.

ADA employment discrimination cases arise at the intersection of disability law and employment, which frequently overlaps with workers’ compensation when an employer’s response to an injured worker’s restrictions implicates the Americans with Disabilities Act.

Attorney Profiles

Mark Buterbaugh is the lead attorney at Mooney Law. His recognitions include National Trial Lawyers Top 25 Workers’ Compensation Attorney in Pennsylvania, Super Lawyers and Rising Star listings, a 9.5 Avvo rating, and the Clients Choice Award 2024. His dual licensure in Pennsylvania and Maryland reflects the geographic reality of his practice area.

His named employer clients in the Hanover and Lebanon areas include Hanover Foods, Snyder’s Lance, Utz Potato Chips, Bendix CVS Company, WellSpan Hanover Hospital, Hershey Foods, Amazon Distribution, Dollar General, New Penn Motor Express, and Bell and Evans, giving a concrete picture of the workforce he represents.

Location and Service Area

Mooney Law operates five offices in south-central Pennsylvania:

  • Chambersburg: 80 North Second Street, Chambersburg, PA 17201
  • Carlisle: 213 South Hanover Street, Carlisle, PA 17013
  • Shippensburg: 34 West King Street, Shippensburg, PA 17257
  • Hanover: 230 York Street, Hanover, PA 17331
  • Lebanon: 346 S. Ninth Street, Lebanon, PA

Main phone: 717-200-HELP. Hanover and Lebanon: 717-632-4656.

The firm covers Franklin, Cumberland, Adams, York, Lancaster, Lebanon, and surrounding counties, and handles Maryland claims for clients who work across the state line. Consultations are free and available Monday through Friday 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM by phone, Zoom, or in person.

The firm’s website is at centralpaworkerscomp.com.

Client Focus

Mooney Law serves the workers of south-central Pennsylvania’s major industries: warehouse and distribution workers along the I-81 corridor, manufacturing employees, healthcare workers, food processing workers, and the range of other occupations present in the region’s economy. The firm’s recognition of the specific employers where their clients work, including Amazon Distribution, Hershey Foods, and Utz Potato Chips, reflects a practice genuinely embedded in this regional workforce.

For workers injured while employed in Maryland but living in Pennsylvania, Buterbaugh’s dual-state licensure eliminates the need to find a Maryland attorney separately. This is a practical service to the cross-border commuter population that is substantial in this part of the state.

The firm’s five-office structure means a Mooney Law location is within reasonable reach of clients across a large portion of south-central Pennsylvania.

Frequently Asked Questions

What workers’ compensation benefits are available in Pennsylvania?
Pennsylvania workers’ compensation provides wage loss benefits, typically two-thirds of pre-injury average weekly wage, while a worker is unable to perform their job. It also covers medical expenses related to the work injury. When an employer attempts to stop or reduce benefits, the firm litigates to protect the worker’s rights.

What is an Independent Medical Examination and how does it affect my claim?
An IME is a medical examination requested by the employer’s insurance carrier and conducted by a doctor selected by the insurer. These examinations are often used to generate medical opinions supporting a reduction or termination of benefits. Having an attorney involved before and after an IME helps protect a worker’s claim from the adverse opinions these examinations frequently produce.

Can Mooney Law handle my claim if I was injured in Maryland while living in Pennsylvania?
Yes. Mark Buterbaugh is licensed in both Pennsylvania and Maryland. He handles Maryland Workers’ Compensation Commission claims for Pennsylvania residents who are injured while working in Maryland.

What is a workers’ compensation settlement?
A workers’ compensation settlement is a lump sum payment that resolves a workers’ compensation claim in exchange for the injured worker giving up future benefits, including future medical payments related to the injury. Whether to settle, and at what amount, depends on the specific facts of the injury, the extent of permanent impairment, future medical needs, and age and wage factors. Buterbaugh negotiates these settlements and litigates when insurers do not offer fair amounts.

What should I do after a dog bite in Pennsylvania?
After a dog bite, get the owner’s contact and insurance information, gather witness contacts, photograph the injuries, report the attack to animal control, and seek medical care. Under Pennsylvania law, owners can be held responsible for attacks even if the dog had not previously bitten anyone, particularly if the owner was aware of the dog’s aggressive tendencies. Call Mooney Law for a free consultation.

How are warehouse injuries handled?
Warehouse injuries, which include forklift accidents, slip and falls, loading dock injuries, and repetitive stress injuries from order picking and material handling, are a significant part of Mooney Law’s practice along the I-81 corridor. These claims proceed through Pennsylvania’s workers’ compensation system with the same legal protections as any other work injury.

Closing

Mark Buterbaugh grew up in the communities Mooney Law serves, and his five-office presence across south-central Pennsylvania reflects a practice designed for the workers of this region. From warehouse employees along the I-81 corridor to food processing workers at the region’s major manufacturers, to Pennsylvania residents injured on the job in Maryland, Mooney Law has recovered tens of millions of dollars in workers’ compensation benefits across Franklin, Cumberland, Adams, York, Lancaster, and Lebanon counties.

Free consultations are available at 717-200-HELP, Monday through Friday 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM. Full information is at centralpaworkerscomp.com.

Remarks left by readers

Leave a remark on this listing

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *