Introduction
Among the trial attorneys practicing in St. Joseph County, Indiana, Andrew B. Jones holds a distinction that only a small number of his colleagues can claim: he has served as lead counsel at trial in both civil and criminal defense matters. Those are separate disciplines requiring different skill sets, courtroom strategies, and bodies of law, and most attorneys who try cases focus on one or the other. Jones has done both, an accomplishment recognized by AVVO. His South Bend practice covers personal injury and wrongful death, medical malpractice, criminal defense, divorce and family law, small business counseling, appeals, and a distinctive specialty that few law offices anywhere handle: academic misconduct representation for students facing disciplinary proceedings at colleges and universities.
The firm operates with an intentional structure: Andrew Jones as lead trial attorney and Michael Smyth as Of Counsel for appellate work and complex motion practice. Smyth’s embedded appellate role means that when a case requires a sophisticated brief, a complex response to opposing counsel’s motion, or an appeal in civil or criminal proceedings, there is a specialist whose work centers on exactly that function. Free consultations are available.
Practice Areas
Jones Law Office LLC covers a range of practice areas that reflects Andrew Jones’s trial experience across civil and criminal matters.
Active practice areas include:
- Personal injury and wrongful death
- Medical malpractice
- Small business counseling
- Criminal defense
- Divorce and family law
- Academic misconduct representation
- Appeals
The academic misconduct practice is worth specific attention because it is uncommon. When a student at a college or university is accused of violating the institution’s code of conduct: whether for alleged cheating, plagiarism, academic fraud, or other infractions: the student faces proceedings that are governed by institutional rules rather than the rules of a court. These proceedings can result in suspension, expulsion, notation on a transcript, or revocation of degrees. The consequences can affect employment prospects, graduate school admissions, and professional licensing. Students in these situations often do not know they can retain an attorney, or that doing so can significantly affect the outcome. Jones Law Office handles these cases, applying legal analytical skills to a quasi-judicial setting that requires understanding the institution’s own procedures and the student’s rights within them.
The appeals practice, handled primarily through Michael Smyth’s Of Counsel role, covers both civil and criminal cases. Appeals require a different skill set from trial work: the record is fixed, oral argument is limited, and the written brief is the primary vehicle for persuasion. Smyth’s focus on researching and composing complex motions, responses, and briefs makes him a specialist in exactly the kind of analytical, research-intensive work that appeals demand.
Attorney Profiles
Andrew B. Jones is the firm’s lead attorney. His standing as one of only a few St. Joseph County trial attorneys to have served as lead counsel in both civil and criminal defense trials is not a credential that is awarded: it is a record of what he has actually done in courtrooms in the county. AVVO recognition reinforces that record with an external assessment, but the primary credential is the trial history itself.
Practicing across civil and criminal matters requires fluency in two distinct bodies of law, procedural systems, and advocacy approaches. Civil litigation: particularly personal injury and medical malpractice cases: involves discovery processes, expert witnesses, damages calculations, and negotiation dynamics that are distinct from criminal defense, which involves constitutional protections, evidentiary suppression motions, and the specific dynamics of criminal trials. Attorneys who develop genuine trial competence in both areas are rare.
Michael Smyth serves the firm as Of Counsel with a specific function: researching and composing complex motions, responses, and briefs, and conducting appeals in civil and criminal cases. The embedded appellate counsel model means the firm does not need to refer clients to outside appellate specialists when a case generates a motion to suppress, a post-trial motion, or a need for an appeal. That capability resides within the firm through Smyth’s dedicated practice.
Location and Service Area
Jones Law Office LLC is located in South Bend, Indiana. The phone number is 574-239-7017. The website is attorney-jones.com/.
Service covers St. Joseph County and surrounding areas. South Bend is the county seat of St. Joseph County and the economic center of the broader region, meaning the firm’s location places it at the hub of the legal activity it serves.
Client Focus
Initial consultations at Jones Law Office are free. This applies across all practice areas, including the specialized academic misconduct practice where students may be unfamiliar with the process and unsure whether legal help is available or appropriate.
Personal injury and wrongful death cases in Indiana follow Indiana’s specific statute of limitations and damages frameworks. Medical malpractice cases in Indiana have specific procedural prerequisites, including a requirement for review by a medical review panel before a case can be filed in court. This panel review process adds time and procedural complexity to medical malpractice claims that does not exist in standard personal injury cases. Having an attorney familiar with Indiana’s specific medical malpractice requirements is important from the earliest stages of the case.
Criminal defense in St. Joseph County involves practice before the local criminal courts, and Andrew Jones’s record of lead-counsel trials in this jurisdiction gives him direct familiarity with the local judicial environment. Courtroom familiarity: knowing how specific judges manage proceedings, what local practice customs prevail, and how cases typically move through the system: is a practical advantage that attorneys with extensive local trial experience have over those with more limited local exposure.
Divorce and family law cases in Indiana involve specific statutory frameworks for property division, child custody, child support, and spousal maintenance. Indiana law uses an equal division presumption for marital property that can be rebutted by relevant factors. Child custody determinations are governed by the best interests of the child standard, applied through a specific set of statutory factors. Family law cases also have their own emotional dynamics that require attorneys who can maintain analytical clarity while also understanding the human dimensions of what clients are going through.
Small business counseling reflects a service line relevant to South Bend’s business community. Small businesses need legal assistance with entity formation, contract drafting and review, employment matters, and dispute resolution. Having litigation-experienced counsel for business matters means that if a contractual dispute escalates to litigation, the attorney already knows the business, its operations, and the facts of the dispute.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is academic misconduct representation and why would a student need an attorney?
Colleges and universities have their own disciplinary processes, governed by institutional policies rather than court rules. When a student faces a hearing for alleged academic dishonesty, plagiarism, or other code of conduct violations, the outcome can be suspension, expulsion, or a permanent notation on their academic record. An attorney familiar with these proceedings can analyze the institution’s policies, advise on the student’s rights within the process, help prepare for the hearing, and assist in appealing an adverse decision. Many students and families do not realize legal representation is available or how much it can matter.
What is the benefit of having embedded appellate counsel?
Appeals require a specific form of legal argument: analyzing a factual and legal record that is already closed, identifying issues that have been preserved for appellate review, and crafting written arguments that persuade an appellate panel. Michael Smyth’s practice centers on exactly this work. Having that capability within the firm means clients who need an appeal or a complex motion do not have to start over with a new attorney who does not know the case.
What makes lead-counsel trial experience significant?
Lead counsel at trial is responsible for the entire courtroom strategy: examining and cross-examining witnesses, making and arguing legal motions in real time, presenting opening and closing arguments, and responding to the opposing party’s case. Attorneys who have led trials, rather than serving in supporting roles, have developed a specific set of skills under genuine adversarial pressure. Very few attorneys in any jurisdiction have tried cases on both the civil and criminal sides.
What is Indiana’s medical malpractice review panel requirement?
Indiana law requires that before a medical malpractice lawsuit can be filed in court, the proposed complaint must first be submitted to a medical review panel composed of medical professionals. The panel reviews the case and issues a non-binding opinion about whether the evidence supports a conclusion that the defendant deviated from the applicable standard of care. This process adds months to the timeline of a medical malpractice case and requires careful preparation of the submission materials. The panel’s opinion, while not binding, can influence how the subsequent litigation proceeds.
Does the firm handle criminal appeals in addition to trial defense?
Yes. Through Michael Smyth’s appellate practice, the firm handles appeals in criminal cases. Criminal appeals require identifying issues that were properly preserved at the trial level: errors in the admission or exclusion of evidence, improper jury instructions, constitutional violations, and similar grounds. The appellate brief must frame these issues persuasively within the specific standards that govern criminal appellate review in Indiana.
Closing
One trial attorney whose lead-counsel record spans both civil and criminal courtrooms, one dedicated appellate specialist handling complex motions and appeals, a practice that extends into the uncommon territory of academic misconduct representation, and free consultations across all practice areas: Jones Law Office LLC serves St. Joseph County and surrounding Indiana communities from a base of real trial experience.
The phone number is 574-239-7017. The website is attorney-jones.com/. The firm is in South Bend, Indiana.