Go to the listings
Attorney Index US

Clawson Fargnoli Utsey, LLC

Profile brought up to date

Introduction

Nearly 65 years of combined litigation experience, accumulated by attorneys who have sat on both sides of the courtroom, is what distinguishes Clawson Fargnoli Utsey, LLC from many Charleston personal injury firms. The four attorneys at this boutique practice have represented both plaintiffs and defendants in personal injury matters, giving them an insider’s understanding of how insurance companies build their defenses and where those defenses are most vulnerable.

The firm occupies The Presqui’le House at 2 Amherst Street in Charleston, South Carolina. This location in one of the Southeast’s most storied cities reflects a firm that has built its reputation through sustained, high-quality litigation work rather than volume advertising. Clawson Fargnoli Utsey operates on the premise that injured people are real people with real challenges, and that the attorney-client relationship should reflect that reality at every stage of a case.

The firm has successfully recovered millions of dollars for clients across a wide spectrum of personal injury cases. What makes this record significant is more than the aggregate figure but the breadth of case types that contributed to it, from maritime law and admiralty claims to nursing home abuse to Title IX cases. This range reflects legal capability that goes well beyond the standard personal injury practice.

Practice Areas

Vehicle and Transportation Accidents

Car accidents, truck accidents, motorcycle accidents, bicycle accidents, pedestrian accidents, and drunk driving accidents form the foundation of the firm’s caseload. The attorneys understand how to investigate collision scenes, work with accident reconstruction experts, and build the evidentiary record needed to prove both liability and damages.

Boating and Water Accidents

Charleston’s coastal geography makes boating and water recreation a significant part of life in the Lowcountry. The firm handles boating accidents, jet ski accidents, and maritime law cases, including admiralty claims that arise on navigable waters and may involve different legal frameworks than standard land-based tort cases.

Premises Liability

Property owners have legal obligations to maintain safe conditions for visitors. When those obligations are breached and someone is injured, the firm pursues claims for slip and fall accidents, dangerous property conditions, and negligent security. Cases involving government-owned properties present additional complexity, and the firm handles government liability claims as well.

Medical and Product Cases

Prescription errors and defective products cases require careful investigation and often expert testimony to establish how a product or medical error caused harm. The firm handles these technically demanding cases with the litigation skill needed to challenge well-resourced defendants.

Specialized Practice Areas

The firm’s case portfolio includes areas that many personal injury practices do not handle: police chase accidents where government entities may bear liability, malicious prosecution claims for individuals subjected to groundless legal action, liquor liability cases involving establishments that overserved patrons, insurance bad faith claims when insurers unreasonably deny or delay legitimate claims, and Title IX cases. Workers’ compensation, wrongful arrest, and wrongful death round out a comprehensive practice.

Nursing Home Abuse

Elderly residents of nursing facilities deserve protection and dignified care. When facilities fail in their duty of care, through understaffing, inadequate training, or outright abuse, the attorneys at Clawson Fargnoli Utsey pursue accountability for injured residents and their families.

Attorney Profiles

Sam Clawson Jr.

Sam Clawson Jr. is one of the firm’s founding attorneys. Client testimonials specifically name him alongside Christy Fargnoli for treating clients with respect from the outset of representation, a quality that matters enormously to people navigating difficult circumstances after an injury.

Christy Fargnoli

Christy Fargnoli has earned client recognition for her no-nonsense approach to case handling. Client Teresa Z. described Fargnoli’s representation as exceeding expectations, citing her direct, results-focused manner. Client Paula D. similarly highlighted the respectful treatment she received from Fargnoli and Clawson throughout their case.

Bert “Skip” Utsey

Bert Utsey, known as Skip, brings substantial litigation experience to the firm’s work across its practice areas. His background contributing to the firm’s collective track record reflects the depth of trial experience the firm brings to each case.

Laura Wilkes D’Amato

Laura Wilkes D’Amato rounds out a four-attorney team that collectively spans nearly 65 years of litigation experience. The combined tenure and the firm’s experience representing both sides of personal injury cases give the attorneys an understanding of litigation dynamics that benefits their plaintiff clients.

Location and Service Area

Clawson Fargnoli Utsey, LLC represents clients throughout South Carolina from their Charleston office.

Address: The Presqui’le House, 2 Amherst Street, Charleston, SC 29403
Phone: (843) 970-2700
Website: cfulaw.com

Free consultations are available for prospective clients to discuss their cases without financial obligation.

Client Focus

The firm’s stated philosophy is that clients are real people facing real challenges, a commitment that shapes how the attorneys approach communication, case strategy, and client relationships. Nicholas P., a former client, described the firm as making him feel like family in a professional environment. This combination of personal attention and skilled advocacy reflects what the firm offers: boutique-scale care with the litigation firepower of experienced trial lawyers.

The dual experience of representing both plaintiffs and defendants is not incidental to the firm’s value proposition. It means the attorneys understand how insurance adjusters evaluate cases, what defenses opposing counsel will raise, and where the pressure points are in settlement negotiations. Clients benefit from this perspective at every stage of a case, from the initial demand letter through trial if one becomes necessary.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Clawson Fargnoli Utsey different from other Charleston personal injury firms?

The firm’s attorneys have represented both plaintiffs and defendants in personal injury litigation, giving them direct insight into how insurance companies and defense counsel approach cases. This experience, combined with nearly 65 years of collective litigation experience, positions the firm to anticipate and counter defense strategies more effectively than attorneys who have only worked on one side of these cases.

What types of injury cases does the firm handle?

The firm handles an unusually wide range of personal injury cases: vehicle accidents of all types, boating and maritime claims, premises liability, product liability, prescription errors, nursing home abuse, wrongful death, workers’ compensation, police chase accidents, liquor liability, insurance bad faith, malicious prosecution, wrongful arrest, and Title IX cases, among others.

Does the firm offer free consultations?

Yes. The firm offers free consultations so prospective clients can discuss their situation and understand their options without any financial obligation.

Does the firm represent clients outside Charleston?

Yes. The attorneys represent clients throughout South Carolina, not solely in the Charleston metro area.

How has the firm performed for clients financially?

The firm has successfully recovered millions of dollars for clients across its caseload. The specific outcome of any individual case depends on its facts, but this track record reflects sustained litigation success across a broad range of case types.

Closing

Four attorneys with nearly 65 years of combined experience, a history of representing both sides of personal injury litigation, and millions recovered for South Carolina clients, Clawson Fargnoli Utsey, LLC offers Charleston-area injury victims a level of insight and skill that is difficult to find in a boutique firm. Client testimonials consistently describe attorneys who treat people with respect, communicate clearly, and deliver results. Reach the firm at (843) 970-2700 or visit cfulaw.com to arrange a free consultation.

Other firms in the same city and field

Remarks left by readers

Leave a remark on this listing

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *