Reeder & Nussbaum, P.A.
Profile brought up to date
Introduction
Both Andrew Reeder and Marc Nussbaum spent the early portions of their legal careers defending insurance companies. That experience gave them firsthand knowledge of how insurers evaluate claims, deploy delay tactics, and calculate the minimum they can pay to resolve a case. With over 44 years of combined experience and more than $50 million recovered for clients, the partners now use that insider perspective at Reeder & Nussbaum, P.A., located at 2201 4th Street North, Suite G, St. Petersburg, Florida 33704. The firm is available 24/7 at (732) 521-2889, (813) 657-2889, or toll-free at 877-449-2889, with services in both English and Spanish.
Practice Areas
Car and Auto Accidents
The firm handles the full spectrum of car accident claims: rear-end collisions, head-on crashes, T-bone impacts, sideswipe incidents, DUI-related accidents, distracted driving cases, hit-and-run incidents, and rideshare (Uber/Lyft) collisions. Over 90% of the firm’s cases settle without litigation, a resolution rate that reflects the strength of case preparation and the partners’ understanding of what motivates insurance carriers to offer fair settlements.
Motorcycle Accidents
Motorcycle riders face higher injury severity and persistent bias from insurance adjusters. The firm represents injured motorcyclists, countering the assumption of rider fault that frequently diminishes the value of legitimate claims.
Trucking Accidents
Commercial truck crashes involve Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration regulations, multiple liable parties, and injuries that are typically severe. The firm pursues these cases against drivers, trucking companies, and other parties whose negligence contributed to the collision.
Medical Malpractice
Healthcare providers who fall below the standard of care cause injuries that range from misdiagnosis to surgical errors to medication mistakes. The firm handles these cases with the expert medical testimony and detailed documentation that malpractice litigation demands.
Slip and Fall
Property owner negligence causes injuries in commercial buildings, parking lots, residential complexes, and public spaces. The firm pursues premises liability claims against property owners who fail to maintain safe conditions.
Dram Shop and Liquor Liability
Florida’s dram shop law allows injured parties to pursue claims against establishments that serve alcohol to minors or to individuals known to be habitually addicted to alcohol. The firm handles these cases when overservice at bars, restaurants, or events leads to injuries.
Nursing Home Abuse and Neglect
Elderly residents of nursing facilities are vulnerable to physical abuse, neglect, medication errors, and inadequate care. The firm represents residents and their families in holding facilities accountable for failures that cause harm.
Insurance Bad Faith
When insurers unreasonably delay, deny, or underpay valid claims, Florida law provides remedies beyond the original claim amount. The firm pursues bad faith actions against carriers who fail to meet their contractual and statutory obligations.
Wrongful Death
Fatal accidents, medical errors, and other acts of negligence give rise to wrongful death claims. The firm represents surviving family members in pursuing compensation for their losses.
Additional Practice Areas
The firm also handles back, neck, and spinal cord injuries, pedestrian and bicycle accidents, PIP claims and windshield litigation, Exactech recall cases, and JUUL-related claims.
Attorney Profiles
Andrew Reeder serves as a partner at the firm. His background as a former insurance defense attorney gives him direct knowledge of the strategies carriers use to minimize and deny claims.
Marc Nussbaum serves as the other named partner, bringing complementary insurance defense experience that strengthens the firm’s ability to anticipate and counter insurer tactics.
Location and Contact
Reeder & Nussbaum, P.A. is located at 2201 4th Street North, Suite G, St. Petersburg, Florida 33704.
Phone: (727) 521-2889 / (813) 657-2889 / Toll-free: 877-449-2889
The firm serves clients in St. Petersburg, Tampa, Clearwater, and throughout Pinellas, Hillsborough, Sarasota, Pasco, and Manatee counties, as well as the broader Florida region. Free consultations are available 24/7. The firm works on a contingency fee basis. Spanish-speaking staff are available.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does the firm’s insurance defense background matter?
Both founding partners previously represented insurance companies. They know how insurers internally evaluate claims, what triggers higher settlement authority, and which defense strategies are deployed at each stage. That knowledge directly benefits their clients.
What percentage of cases settle without going to trial?
Over 90% of the firm’s cases settle without litigation. This high resolution rate reflects thorough case preparation and strategic negotiation informed by the partners’ understanding of insurer behavior.
Does the firm offer services in Spanish?
Yes. Spanish-speaking staff are available to assist clients who prefer to communicate in Spanish.
Is the firm available outside of business hours?
Yes. Reeder & Nussbaum offers 24/7 availability for consultations and client communication.
Leave a remark on this listing