Go to the listings
Attorney Index US

Introduction

Founded in 1964 in Athens, Georgia, Cook & Tolley, LLP has spent over half a century building a practice that spans high-stakes personal injury litigation, medical malpractice, criminal defense, and civil litigation. Managing partner J. Vincent “Jay” Cook has been specializing in medical malpractice since the 1970s with board certification, and his list of leadership positions, including past president of the State Bar of Georgia, reads like a roadmap of the state’s legal institutions. With five attorneys selected to Super Lawyers or Rising Stars lists and an AV Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell, the firm operates across the state from Atlanta to Savannah, Columbus to Valdosta, and Augusta to Albany.

Practice Areas

Medical Malpractice

Medical malpractice has been a cornerstone of the firm’s practice since the 1970s. Managing partner Jay Cook holds board certification in this area and teaches the medical malpractice course at the University of Georgia School of Law. The firm handles cases where healthcare providers have caused harm through negligent treatment, misdiagnosis, surgical errors, and other deviations from the standard of care.

Personal Injury

Cook & Tolley represents injury victims in a comprehensive range of cases including slips and falls, commercial truck crashes, auto collisions, animal bites, negligent security injuries, premises liability accidents, and bicycle or pedestrian wrecks. The attorneys investigate each case thoroughly, create tailored plans of action, and pursue maximum compensation. The firm operates on a contingency fee basis, which in Georgia typically ranges between 33% and 45% of the recovery.

Criminal Defense

The firm’s criminal defense practice traces its roots to Edward Tolley, who joined in 1976 and became one of the state’s preeminent criminal defense lawyers. The practice handles serious criminal charges with the same thorough preparation and courtroom skill that defines the firm’s civil work.

Civil and Business Litigation

Beyond personal injury and criminal defense, Cook & Tolley handles civil and business litigation matters. This includes commercial disputes, contract conflicts, and other civil cases where the firm’s trial experience and preparation provide a decisive advantage.

Attorney Profiles

J. Vincent “Jay” Cook

Managing partner Jay Cook founded the firm in 1964 and has been practicing medical malpractice law since the 1970s with board certification. He has served as president of the State Bar of Georgia, president of the Georgia Civil Justice Foundation, president of the Georgia Trial Lawyers Association, president of the Georgia Chapter of the American Board of Trial Advocates, and president of the Western Circuit Bar Association. He teaches the medical malpractice course at the University of Georgia School of Law.

Edward Tolley

Edward Tolley joined the firm in 1976 and built a reputation as one of Georgia’s preeminent criminal defense lawyers. He also developed expertise in civil and business litigation, earning sustained co-billing that placed his name in the firm’s title.

Location and Contact

Cook & Tolley, LLP is located at 304 East Washington Street, Athens, Georgia 30601. Phone: (706) 549-6111. The firm serves clients throughout Georgia and accepts personal injury cases on a contingency fee basis.

cooktolley.com/

Frequently Asked Questions

How long has Cook & Tolley been practicing?
The firm was founded in 1964, giving it over 60 years of continuous legal practice in Georgia. Medical malpractice has been a focus since the 1970s.

What areas of Georgia does the firm serve?
Cook & Tolley serves clients across the entire state of Georgia, from Atlanta and Savannah to Columbus, Valdosta, Augusta, Albany, and their surrounding communities, including Jefferson and other cities in Jackson County.

Does the firm charge upfront fees for personal injury cases?
No. Personal injury cases are handled on a contingency fee basis, meaning the firm collects fees only from the settlement or verdict amount. In Georgia, contingency fees typically range between 33% and 45%.

What is an AV Preeminent rating?
The AV Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell represents the highest level of professional excellence, based on peer reviews from attorneys and members of the judiciary. It reflects both legal ability and ethical standards.

What makes Jay Cook’s medical malpractice experience notable?
Beyond decades of practice with board certification, Jay Cook has held leadership positions in multiple state legal organizations and teaches the medical malpractice course at the University of Georgia School of Law, combining practical trial experience with academic expertise.

Other firms in the same city and field

Remarks left by readers

Leave a remark on this listing

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *