Carls Law, PLLC
Profile brought up to date
Introduction
Before founding her own litigation firm, Hillary P. Carls clerked for Chief Judge Robert Coats of the Alaska Court of Appeals, played four years of varsity golf for Montana State University’s Big Sky Conference team as an all-conference player, and earned a Certificate in Environmental and Natural Resources Law alongside her J.D. from Northwestern School of Law at Lewis and Clark College in 2005. She has practiced law in Montana since 2006, and currently serves as President-Elect of the Montana Trial Lawyers Association.
Carls Law, PLLC operates from 322 West Mendenhall in Bozeman, Montana, handling litigation with a primary focus on personal injury, insurance disputes, and class actions.
Practice Areas
Carls Law, PLLC concentrates on litigation matters, with Hillary P. Carls personally handling the most complex and high-stakes cases the firm takes on.
Practice areas include:
- Catastrophic personal injuries and wrongful death
- Brain injuries and concussions
- Insurance disputes
- Class actions
- Police misconduct
- Wrongful incarceration
- Gender discrimination
- Car accidents
- Slip and fall accidents
The catastrophic injury category encompasses cases where the severity of harm is life-altering: permanent disability, severe brain injury, spinal damage, and death. These cases require expert witnesses, life care planning testimony, and often extended litigation against well-resourced insurance companies and defendants.
Brain injury and concussion cases have gained increased attention in recent years as the medical community has developed better understanding of traumatic brain injury severity and long-term consequences. Cases the firm handles include both obvious traumatic brain injuries from high-force impacts and more subtle concussive injuries whose effects accumulate over time.
Insurance dispute work positions the firm against insurance carriers rather than negligent third parties. When insurance companies deny claims, undervalue losses, or act in bad faith, policyholders have legal remedies. The firm has litigation experience in this area that goes beyond standard personal injury practice.
Police misconduct and wrongful incarceration cases involve constitutional claims against government actors. These cases require understanding of federal civil rights law under Section 1983, qualified immunity doctrine, and the procedural requirements specific to suing government entities.
Gender discrimination cases add an employment law dimension to the firm’s civil rights practice.
Attorney Profiles
Hillary P. Carls is the founder and partner at Carls Law, PLLC. Her educational background is specific: B.A. in Business from Montana State University in Bozeman in 2001, J.D. with Certificate in Environmental and Natural Resources Law from Northwestern School of Law at Lewis and Clark College in 2005. She clerked for Chief Judge Robert Coats of the Alaska Court of Appeals before beginning her Montana practice in 2006.
Before founding Carls Law, PLLC, she was a partner at three Bozeman law firms: Angel, Coil & Bartlett; Dodd, Blackford & Carls, P.C.; and Blackford Carls, P.C. That sequence of partnerships reflects a career building toward an independent practice.
She is licensed to practice before the State of Montana, the Montana Supreme Court, the United States District Court of Montana, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
Professional affiliations include the Montana Trial Lawyers Association (currently serving as President-Elect), the Montana Bar Association, the Gallatin County Bar Association, and the American Association for Justice. She has served on the boards of the Montana Ballet Company, Keystone Conservation, and Bridger Care, Inc.
Location and Service Area
Carls Law, PLLC is located at:
322 West Mendenhall
Bozeman, Montana
Phone: 406.577.2145
Fax: 406.219.0256
Bozeman is the seat of Gallatin County and the largest city in southwest Montana, situated in the Gallatin Valley between the Bridger Range to the north and the Spanish Peaks Wilderness to the south. The firm is positioned to serve clients throughout Montana given its Ninth Circuit and U.S. District Court of Montana admission.
More information is available at carlslaw.com/
Client Focus
Carls Law, PLLC serves Montana residents who have suffered serious injuries or civil rights violations and need an attorney with specific litigation experience in those categories. The firm is not a high-volume practice. Hillary Carls concentrates on disputes involving catastrophic injuries, which typically require more preparation time, more expert involvement, and more extended litigation than standard vehicle accident cases.
Her background in environmental and natural resources law adds relevant context for Montana-specific cases, particularly those involving outdoor recreation injuries or land-related incidents common in the region.
The Montana Trial Lawyers Association President-Elect position reflects active involvement in the plaintiff litigation community and access to the network of experts, co-counsel, and litigation resources that comes with that engagement.
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of cases does Carls Law, PLLC handle?
The firm handles personal injury cases including catastrophic injuries, wrongful death, brain injuries and concussions, car accidents, and slip and fall accidents. Additional practice areas include insurance disputes, class actions, police misconduct, wrongful incarceration, and gender discrimination.
Where is Hillary P. Carls licensed to practice?
She is licensed before the State of Montana, the Montana Supreme Court, the United States District Court of Montana, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
What is Hillary Carls professional background before founding the firm?
She earned her J.D. from Northwestern School of Law at Lewis and Clark College in 2005 with a Certificate in Environmental and Natural Resources Law. She clerked for Chief Judge Robert Coats of the Alaska Court of Appeals and was previously a partner at three Bozeman law firms before founding Carls Law, PLLC.
What professional organizations is Hillary Carls involved with?
She currently serves as President-Elect of the Montana Trial Lawyers Association and is a member of the Montana Bar Association, the Gallatin County Bar Association, and the American Association for Justice.
Does the firm handle federal cases?
Yes. Hillary P. Carls is admitted to the United States District Court of Montana and the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, allowing her to handle federal civil rights claims and other federal matters in addition to state court litigation.
How do I reach Carls Law, PLLC?
Call 406.577.2145 or visit carlslaw.com/ for more information.
Closing
Carls Law, PLLC represents a specific profile: a litigation-focused practice built on nearly two decades of Montana legal work, Ninth Circuit admission, and concentrated experience in the highest-stakes civil cases including catastrophic injury, police misconduct, wrongful incarceration, and insurance bad faith. Hillary Carls brings organizational leadership as Montana Trial Lawyers Association President-Elect alongside her courtroom and litigation experience.
For Montana residents facing serious civil legal matters, contact Carls Law, PLLC at 406.577.2145 or visit carlslaw.com/
Leave a remark on this listing